WHO GOT UPSET WHEN THEY FIRST SAW ROTS??

[Dirge]

rots was good not really good like the older films (empire strikes back being my fav) but it was different the battles were to short but i did hate the way the jedi was killed off i mean they were masters they should had put up more off a fight but yoda did own though and obi got to give it up to those two

[chiny5000]

obiwan13 said:

Didn't piss me off, it was a necessary addition to the story.

If the kids were not shown to be killed we would have said "what about the kids?"

Mace's demise was a bit weak but overall not bad. Again had to be shown.

Overall the movie was awesome, I think being P****d off and cursing is a tad overreacting

Agreed ^^



-Darth Sephis

[uths16]

I agree with you Sorrow except ROTS is my fav.

[Commander "Cordo"]

Nope I thought Episode III has the second best story in my opinion (episode I being my fav.) It had the best effects and most action episode II was boring as hell and jango's death made me cry for a week :'(Because it was so pathetic. the only good part was the clone battle/war in the areana except jangos death. ;D

[Mrs. Darth Vader]

uths16 said:

ok,My dad got pissed when he first saw ROTS when order 66 was given and the jedi were killed, but he got even more upset when anakin helped kill mace windu and when they showed anakin about to kill the younglings.
My dad lost it he started cussing like crazy saying he hated Anakin and hated those clone troopers that had killed the jedi, he then ask me if Anakin was my fav character and i said he was my 2nd fav (Grievous is my 1st oviously) since then he has hated episode III.
Have you or anyone you know acted like this??

WOW!!! I am surprised to hear your father went ballistic. Sorry to hear that. I guess you survived your father's wrath.

As to did Anakin in fact kill the children I take it as he did not but Palpatine did. My argument to support this idea is; you never see him actually kill them as you do with the separatists leaders. On the Jedi tape that Obi-Wan plays back the events of the temple only the older people are killed by Anakin. You then see Palpatine there and Anakin kneels before Palpatine and Palpatine tells Anakin to "Arise Lord Vader." So you know that when Anakin was downstairs Palpatine was with him. So Palpatine could easily have done it. Lastly I noticed through out the film every time a character lies he turns away from the one he is lieing to. Of course this is a film device to tip off the audience. Obi-Wan does not look at Padme when he tells her he saw Anakin kill younglings. So I believe that they were killed by Palpatine because Anakin could not bring himself to do it. Were as Anakin could kill the older Jedi because he felt that they hurt him anyway so revenge is ok.

I did not get angry the first viewing but shock. When that ended I got angry in defense of Anakin. I got enraged with Obi-Wan and Especially Padme for betraying her husband. I instantly thought if it were me instead of her. I would have stood by my husband.

[Darth Caedus]

mrsdarthvader said:

uths16 said:

ok,My dad got pissed when he first saw ROTS when order 66 was given and the jedi were killed, but he got even more upset when anakin helped kill mace windu and when they showed anakin about to kill the younglings.
My dad lost it he started cussing like crazy saying he hated Anakin and hated those clone troopers that had killed the jedi, he then ask me if Anakin was my fav character and i said he was my 2nd fav (Grievous is my 1st oviously) since then he has hated episode III.
Have you or anyone you know acted like this??

WOW!!! I am surprised to hear your father went ballistic. Sorry to hear that. I guess you survived your father's wrath.

As to did Anakin in fact kill the children I take it as he did not but Palpatine did. My argument to support this idea is; you never see him actually kill them as you do with the separatists leaders. On the Jedi tape that Obi-Wan plays back the events of the temple only the older people are killed by Anakin. You then see Palpatine there and Anakin kneels before Palpatine and Palpatine tells Anakin to "Arise Lord Vader." So you know that when Anakin was downstairs Palpatine was with him. So Palpatine could easily have done it. Lastly I noticed through out the film every time a character lies he turns away from the one he is lieing to. Of course this is a film device to tip off the audience. Obi-Wan does not look at Padme when he tells her he saw Anakin kill younglings. So I believe that they were killed by Palpatine because Anakin could not bring himself to do it. Were as Anakin could kill the older Jedi because he felt that they hurt him anyway so revenge is ok.

I did not get angry the first viewing but shock. When that ended I got angry in defense of Anakin. I got enraged with Obi-Wan and Especially Padme for betraying her husband. I instantly thought if it were me instead of her. I would have stood by my husband.

Anakin did kill the younglings, not Palpatine, George Lucas even has said so himself on numerous occasions.

- Dark Anakin

[Cadeus]

I wanted to stick my saber up anakins rear for killing the younglings

[Mason Fett]

I didnt get upset over it. I mean while I was watching it and how he killed Mace was kind of a strange feeling. I was already expecting him to go on a rampage like that. Like Ben said in episode 4 to Luke. Vader hunted down and destroyed the Jedi.